I'm sorry to report the shine has come off the penny. Shiny Toy Guns has effectively gutted itself, replacing lead singer Carah Faye Charnow with Sisely Treasure and moving the female lead vocalist spot to something just above a back-up singer. Chad Petree made it extremely clear in front of the sold out Berbatti's Pan crowd that he is The One and that the Shiny Toy Guns stage doesn't have room for another strong and dynamic vocalist. Petree is extremely talented, but what made the band so appealing was the vocal interplay between Petree and Charnow. Without Chanrow Petree is left short, a fact that was clearly reflected in the band's extremely brief and underwhelming show.
The crowd seemed very eager to welcome Treasure with open arms, cheering loudly as she took the stage. Their eagerness was not matched by the band who stashed her towards the back of the stage, under mountains of smoke, and relegated her to the occasional backup vocal. It wasn't until she finally stepped forward to sing lead vocals on one of the bands notable songs, 'Le Disco' that it became clear that gamble to reorganize the band was a bust. As a lead vocalist, Treasure struggled through many of the Shiny Toy Guns' song, never quite connecting with them. Her performance brought very little of herself and seemed more like a mimicry of the recorded music than anything else.
I don't think there would have been as big of a problem if the band really brought her in and shared their new direction, but they don't seem to really have one. The one and only song which they performed from their new album Season of Poison was Ricochet, a Marilyn Mansonesque driving rock song which was ok at best. Treasure did seem more in her element belting out rougher, Pat Benetar like, vocals to a driving beat. But that was it. The only real peek into what the band might someday be.
Unfortunately, most of the 50 minute set was a peek at what the band isn't – they aren't the band they used to be. The Shiny Toy Guns left the crowd stunned as the exited the stage after just 38 minutes. Playing only a couple of songs in their encore, the band was off the stage before 11, less than an hour after initially taking the stage (and they were the headliner).
It's no fun to be a fan of a band and see them take a turn for the worse, especially a band that shows tremendous potential.
The show at Berbatti's Pan reminded me of a quote from Annie Hall: There's an old joke – two elderly women are at a Catskill mountain resort, and one of 'em says, "Boy, the food at this place is really terrible." The other one says, "Yeah, I know; and such small portions."
Here are pictures from the Shiny Toy Guns Concert: